Purpose
Older patient populations commonly have cognitive impairment, which might impact decisional capacity. We examined patients and family caregivers preferences for family involvement in treatment decision making assuming different level of cognitive impairment, and sought to explore the factors associated with the preferences and the degree to which patients and family members agree on preferences.
Materials and Methods
A total of 358 elderly cancer patient and caregiver dyads were recruited from the 11 cancer centers in Korea andwere asked to express their preferences forfamily involvement in treatment decision making using hypothetical scenarios with three different levels of cognitive status (intact, mild impairment, and severe impairment).
Results
Both patients and family caregivers preferred greater family dominance in treatment decision makingwith the increasing the level of cognitive impairment (39.7%, 60.9%, and 86.6% for patients and 45.0%, 66.2%, and 89.7% for caregivers in each scenarios). Patient and family caregiver concordance in decisional control preference was small for all three scenarios (weighted κ=0.32, κ=0.26, and κ=0.36, respectively). Higher patient education was associated with preference for patient dominance in treatment decision in conditions of both mild and severe cognitive impairment. The association of higher patient education and patient-caregiver preference concordance was positive with intact cognition, while it was negative with severe cognitive impairment.
Conclusion
Decision control preferences were affected by hypothesized cognitive status of the patients. Findings from our study would be helpful to develop effective strategy for optimizing family involvement in cancer treatment decision in the context of deteriorating cognitive function of the patients.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Comorbid Dementia and Cancer Therapy Decision-Making: A Scoping Review Sean N. Halpin, Gabriel Alain, Aaron Seaman, Erin E. Stevens, Hui Zhao, Mackenzie E. Fowler, Qiuyang Zhang, Tamara Cadet, Minzhi Ye, Jessica L. Krok-Schoen Journal of Applied Gerontology.2024; 43(8): 1132. CrossRef
Assessing the association between quantity and quality of family caregiver participation in decision-making clinical encounters on patient activation in the metastatic breast cancer setting Nicole L. Henderson, Tanvi Padalkar, Garrett Bourne, Emma K. Hendrix, Courtney P. Williams, J. Nicholas Odom, Kristen Triebel, Gabrielle B. Rocque Supportive Care in Cancer.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Fatalism and metaphor in Confucianism: A qualitative study of barriers to genetic testing among first‐degree relatives of hereditary cancer patients from China Chaonan Jiang, Li Liu, Ye Wang, Liangzheng Wu, Wenxia Zhang, Xiaodan Wu Psycho-Oncology.2023; 32(2): 275. CrossRef
The Role of Nurse on the Treatment Decision Support for Older People with Cancer: A Systematic Review Hiroko Komatsu, Yasuhiro Komatsu Healthcare.2023; 11(4): 546. CrossRef
A prospective cohort study of decision‐making role preferences of patients with advanced cancer and their family caregivers Semra Ozdemir, Sean Ng, Isha Chaudhry, Chetna Malhotra, Eric Andrew Finkelstein Cancer.2023; 129(9): 1443. CrossRef
Cancer literacy among Jordanian colorectal cancer survivors and informal carers: Qualitative explorations Samar J. Melhem, Shereen Nabhani-Gebara, Reem Kayyali Frontiers in Public Health.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Preferred and actual involvement of caregivers in oncologic treatment decision-making: A systematic review Laura M.L. Tielemans, Kirsten D. van Heugten, Marije E. Hamaker, Inez C. van Walree Journal of Geriatric Oncology.2023; 14(6): 101525. CrossRef
Factors Affecting Patient and Caregiver Preferences for Treatment of Myeloma and Indolent Lymphoma Chia Jie Tan, Melinda Si Yun Tan, Chandramouli Nagarajan, Wee Joo Chng, Yen-Lin Chee, Melissa Ooi, Lawrence Cheng Kiat Ng, Yunxin Chen, Joanne Su Yin Yoong, Xin Yi Wong, Wei-Ying Jen JCO Oncology Practice.2023; 19(12): 1168. CrossRef
The Association Between Mild Cognitive Impairment Diagnosis and Patient Treatment Preferences: a Survey of Older Adults Deborah A. Levine, Andrzej T. Galecki, Brenda L. Plassman, Angela Fagerlin, Lauren P. Wallner, Kenneth M. Langa, Rachael T. Whitney, Brahmajee K. Nallamothu, Lewis B. Morgenstern, Bailey K. Reale, Emilie M. Blair, Bruno Giordani, Kathleen Anne Welsh-Bohme Journal of General Internal Medicine.2022; 37(8): 1925. CrossRef
Patient activation and treatment decision-making in the context of cancer: examining the contribution of informal caregivers’ involvement Chiara Acquati, Judith H. Hibbard, Ellen Miller-Sonet, Anao Zhang, Elena Ionescu Journal of Cancer Survivorship.2022; 16(5): 929. CrossRef
Factors influencing family involvement in treatment decision-making for older patients with cancer: A scoping review Bea L. Dijkman, Marie Louise Luttik, Hanneke Van der Wal-Huisman, Wolter Paans, Barbara L. van Leeuwen Journal of Geriatric Oncology.2022; 13(4): 391. CrossRef
The role of caregivers in the clinical pathway of patients newly diagnosed with breast and prostate cancer: A study protocol Clizia Cincidda, Serena Oliveri, Virginia Sanchini, Gabriella Pravettoni Frontiers in Psychology.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Treatment decision-making for older adults with cancer: A qualitative study Ni Gong, Qianqian Du, Hongyu Lou, Yiheng Zhang, Hengying Fang, Xueying Zhang, Xiaoyu Wu, Ya Meng, Meifen Zhang Nursing Ethics.2021; 28(2): 242. CrossRef
Family Caregiving Situations and Engagement in Advance Care Planning Kyeongmo Kim, Michin Hong, Thomas Buckley Journal of Palliative Medicine.2020; 23(1): 125. CrossRef
What We Talk about When We Talk about Caregiving: The Distribution of Roles in Cancer Patient Caregiving in a Family-Oriented Culture Ansuk Jeong, Dongwook Shin, Jong Hyock Park, Keeho Park Cancer Research and Treatment.2019; 51(1): 141. CrossRef
Experience with age discrimination and attitudes toward ageism in older patients with cancer and their caregivers: A nationwide Korean survey Dong Wook Shin, Keeho Park, Ansuk Jeong, Hyung Kook Yang, So Young Kim, Mihee Cho, Jong Hyock Park Journal of Geriatric Oncology.2019; 10(3): 459. CrossRef
How family caregivers of persons with advanced cancer assist with upstream healthcare decision-making: A qualitative study J. Nicholas Dionne-Odom, Deborah Ejem, Rachel Wells, Amber E. Barnato, Richard A. Taylor, Gabrielle B. Rocque, Yasemin E. Turkman, Matthew Kenny, Nataliya V. Ivankova, Marie A. Bakitas, Michelle Y. Martin, Mojtaba Vaismoradi PLOS ONE.2019; 14(3): e0212967. CrossRef
Haa-Na Song, Se-Il Go, Won Sup Lee, Yire Kim, Hye Jung Choi, Un Seok Lee, Myoung Hee Kang, Gyeong-Won Lee, Hoon-Gu Kim, Jung Hun Kang, Yune Sik Kang, Jeong-Hee Lee, Jin-Myung Jung, Soon Chan Hong
Cancer Res Treat. 2016;48(2):789-797. Published online July 14, 2015
Purpose The purpose of this study is to investigate differences in organ-specific cancer incidence according to the region and population size in Korea.
Materials and Methods We reviewed the data of the cancer registration program of Gyeongnam Regional Cancer Center between 2008 and 2011. Age-standardized rates of cancer incidence were analyzed according to population size of the region and administrative zone.
Results Incidence of thyroid cancer has been increasing rapidly in both urban and rural areas. However, the thyroid cancer incidence was much lower in rural areas than in urban areas and megalopolis such as Seoul. Gastric cancer was relatively more common in rural areas, in megalopolis near the sea (Ulsan, Busan, and Incheon), and other southern provinces (Chungcheongnam-do, Gyeongsangbuk-do, and Gyeongsangnam-do). A detailed analysis in Gyeongsangnam-do revealed that rural areas have relatively low incidence of thyroid and colorectal cancer, and relatively high incidence of gastric and lung cancer compared to urban areas.
Conclusion This study suggests that there are some differences in cancer incidence by population size. Thyroid and colorectal cancer incidence was increasing, and gastric and lung cancer was slightly decreasing in urban areas, whereas gastric and lung cancer incidence still remains high in rural areas.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Rural-urban disparity in cancer burden and care: findings from an Indian cancer registry Divya Khanna, Priyanka Sharma, Atul Budukh, Rajesh Vishwakarma, Anand N. Sharma, Sonali Bagal, Varsha Tripathi, Vijay Kumar Maurya, Pankaj Chaturvedi, Satyajit Pradhan BMC Cancer.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
What is the relationship between the local population change and cancer incidence in patients with dyslipidemia: Evidence of the impact of local extinction in Korea Wonjeong Jeong, Dong‐Woo Choi, Woorim Kim, Kyu‐Tae Han Cancer Medicine.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Health expenditure trajectory and gastric cancer incidence in the National Health Insurance Senior Cohort: a nested case-control study Woo-Ri Lee, Ki-Bong Yoo, Jin-Won Noh, Minjee Lee BMC Health Services Research.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Urban Scaling of Health Outcomes: a Scoping Review Edwin M. McCulley, Pricila H. Mullachery, Ana F. Ortigoza, Daniel A. Rodríguez, Ana V. Diez Roux, Usama Bilal Journal of Urban Health.2022; 99(3): 409. CrossRef
Loss of Novel Diversity in Human Gut Microbiota Associated with Ongoing Urbanization in China Shan Sun, Huijun Wang, Annie Green Howard, Jiguo Zhang, Chang Su, Zhihong Wang, Shufa Du, Anthony A. Fodor, Penny Gordon-Larsen, Bing Zhang, Emily B. Graham mSystems.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Deciphering the impact of urban built environment density on respiratory health using a quasi-cohort analysis of 5495 non-smoking lung cancer cases Lan Wang, Wenyao Sun, Anne Vernez Moudon, Yong-Guan Zhu, Jinfeng Wang, Pingping Bao, Xiaojing Zhao, Xiaoming Yang, Yinghui Jia, Surong Zhang, Shuang Wu, Yuxi Cai Science of The Total Environment.2022; 850: 158014. CrossRef
Difference in medical service use among Korean gastric cancer survivors according to regional healthcare vulnerabilities: a cohort study Sung Hoon Jeong, Jae Hong Joo, Minah Park, Choa Yun, Soo Hyun Kang, Eun-Cheol Park, Yoon Dae Han, Sung-In Jang Supportive Care in Cancer.2022; 30(11): 9233. CrossRef
Apoptotic Effects of Anthocyanins from Vitis coignetiae Pulliat Are Enhanced by Augmented Enhancer of the Rudimentary Homolog (ERH) in Human Gastric Carcinoma MKN28 Cells Cheol Park, Won Sup Lee, Se-Il Go, Sang-Ho Jeong, Jiyun Yoo, Hee-Jae Cha, Young-Joon Lee, Heui-Soo Kim, Sun-Hee Leem, Hye Jung Kim, Gon Sup Kim, Soon-Chan Hong, Yung Hyun Choi International Journal of Molecular Sciences.2021; 22(6): 3030. CrossRef
Current therapeutic options for gastric adenocarcinoma C.R. Akshatha, Smitha Bhat, R. Sindhu, Dharini Shashank, Sarana Rose Sommano, Wanaporn Tapingkae, Ratchadawan Cheewangkoon, Shashanka K. Prasad Saudi Journal of Biological Sciences.2021; 28(9): 5371. CrossRef
Impact of Rurality on National Trends in Thyroid Cancer Incidence and Long‐Term Survival Alexandria D. McDow, Whitney E. Zahnd, Peter Angelos, John D. Mellinger, Sabha Ganai The Journal of Rural Health.2020; 36(3): 326. CrossRef
Predicted Future Mortality Attributed to Increases in Temperature and PM10 Concentration under Representative Concentration Pathway Scenarios Jiyun Jung, Jae Young Lee, Hyewon Lee, Ho Kim International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2020; 17(7): 2600. CrossRef
Polyphenols Extracted from Artemisia annua L. Exhibit Anti-Cancer Effects on Radio-Resistant MDA-MB-231 Human Breast Cancer Cells by Suppressing Stem Cell Phenotype, β-Catenin, and MMP-9 Young Shin Ko, Eun Joo Jung, Se-il Go, Bae Kwon Jeong, Gon Sup Kim, Jin-Myung Jung, Soon Chan Hong, Choong Won Kim, Hye Jung Kim, Won Sup Lee Molecules.2020; 25(8): 1916. CrossRef
Temporal and geographical variations in colorectal cancer incidence in Northern Iran 2004–2013 Susan Hasanpour-Heidari, Abdolreza Fazel, Shahryar Semnani, Seyyed-Reza Khandoozi, Taghi Amiriani, SeyedMehdi Sedaghat, Reza Hosseinpoor, Ramin Azarhoush, Mohammad Poorabbasi, Mohammad Naeimi-Tabiei, Gholamreza Roshandel, Freddie Bray, Elisabete Weiderpas Cancer Epidemiology.2019; 59: 143. CrossRef
Regional Differences in Years of Life Lost in Korea from 1997 to 2015 Dun-Sol Go, Young-Eun Kim, Munkhzul Radnaabaatar, Yunsun Jung, Jaehun Jung, Seok-Jun Yoon Journal of Korean Medical Science.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Morin enhances auranofin anticancer activity by up‐regulation of DR4 and DR5 and modulation of Bcl‐2 through reactive oxygen species generation in Hep3B human hepatocellular carcinoma cells Hyun Hwang‐Bo, Won Sup Lee, Arulkumar Nagappan, Hong Jae Kim, Radha Panchanathan, Cheol Park, Seong‐Hwan Chang, Nam Deuk Kim, Sun‐Hee Leem, Young‐Chae Chang, Taeg Kyu Kwon, Jae Hun Cheong, Gon Sup Kim, Jin‐Myung Jung, Sung Chul Shin, Soon Chan Hong, Yung Phytotherapy Research.2019; 33(5): 1384. CrossRef
The Use of CD44 Variant 9 and Ki-67 Combination Can Predicts Prognosis Better Than Their Single Use in Early Gastric Cancer Se-Il Go, Gyung Hyuck Ko, Won Sup Lee, Jeong-Hee Lee, Sang-Ho Jeong, Young-Joon Lee, Soon Chan Hong, Woo Song Ha Cancer Research and Treatment.2019; 51(4): 1411. CrossRef
Cancer Incidence Trend in the Hebei Spirit Oil Spill Area, from 1999 to 2014: An Ecological Study Kyung-Hwa Choi, Myung-Sook Park, Mina Ha, Jong-Il Hur, Hae-Kwan Cheong International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2018; 15(5): 1006. CrossRef
Gut Microbiota in Tibetan Herdsmen Reflects the Degree of Urbanization Huan Li, Tongtong Li, Xiangzhen Li, Guanhong Wang, Qiang Lin, Jiapeng Qu Frontiers in Microbiology.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
Regional Differences in Years of Life Lost in Korea from 1997 to 2015 Dun-Sol Go, Young-Eun Kim, Munkhzul Radnaabaatar, Yunsun Jung, Jaehun Jung, Seok-Jun Yoon Journal of Korean Medical Science.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
Estimation of the Incidence of Hepatocellular Carcinoma and Cholangiocarcinoma in Songkhla, Thailand, 1989-2013, Using Multiple Imputation Method Seesai Yeesoonsang, Surichai Bilheem, Edward McNeil, Sophon Iamsirithaworn, Chuleeporn Jiraphongsa, Hutcha Sriplung Cancer Research and Treatment.2017; 49(1): 54. CrossRef
Prognostic impact of Ki-67 in patients with gastric cancer—the importance of depth of invasion and histologic differentiation Gyung Hyuck Ko, Se-Il Go, Won Sup Lee, Jeong-Hee Lee, Sang-Ho Jeong, Young-Joon Lee, Soon Chan Hong, Woo Song Ha Medicine.2017; 96(25): e7181. CrossRef
Recent urbanization in China is correlated with a Westernized microbiome encoding increased virulence and antibiotic resistance genes Kathryn Winglee, Annie Green Howard, Wei Sha, Raad Z. Gharaibeh, Jiawu Liu, Donghui Jin, Anthony A. Fodor, Penny Gordon-Larsen Microbiome.2017;[Epub] CrossRef